Research, Science & environment

STEREO, SOHO spacecraft catch comet diving into sun

By Robert Sanders

Solar physicists at the University of California, Berkeley, have tracked a comet through the low solar atmosphere, deeper into the sun than ever before, before it presumably evaporated in the 100,000-degree heat.


This is the comet and its tail as observed by NASA’s twin STEREO spacecraft between March 12 and 14, 2010. The left side is STEREO B (orbiting behind the Earth) and the right is STEREO A (ahead). The outer images are from Cor2, the middle ones are from Cor1 and the inner ones of the solar disk are from the EUVI instruments onboard STEREO. (NASA. UC Berkeley)

Using instruments aboard NASA’s twin STEREO spacecraft, four post-doctoral fellows at UC Berkeley’s Space Sciences Laboratory were able to track the comet as it approached the sun and estimate an approximate time and place of impact. STEREO (Solar TErrestrial RElations Observatory), launched in 2006, consists of identical spacecraft orbiting the sun, one ahead of Earth and one behind Earth, providing a stereo view of the sun.

The researchers then looked at data from the ground-based Mauna Loa Solar Observatory in Hawaii, and found images in the predicted spot of what appears to be a comet approaching the edge of the sun from behind the solar disk.

“We believe this is the first time a comet has been tracked in 3-D space this low down in the solar corona,” said Claire Raftery, a post-doctoral fellow newly arrived at UC Berkeley from Dublin’s Trinity College.

comet approaching the solar limb

Hydrogen-alpha (ultraviolet) observations of the sun's edge from the Coronado instrument of the Mauna Loa Solar Observatory showing what the authors believe to be the comet approaching the solar limb. (Claire Raftery, Juan Carlos Martinez-Oliveros, Samuel Krucker/UC Berkeley)

The team will present its data and images during a 5:30-6:30 p.m. poster session on Monday, May 24, at the Miami, Fla., meeting of the American Astronomical Society.

Sungrazing comets, composed of dust, rock and ice, are seldom tracked close to the sun because their brightness is overwhelmed by the solar disk. This comet apparently survived the heat of the corona and disappeared in the chromosphere, evaporating in the 100,000-degree (Kelvin) heat.

Raftery and her colleagues, Juan Carlos Martinez-Oliveros, Samuel Krucker and Pascal Saint-Hilaire, concluded that the comet was probably one of the Kreutz family of comets, a swarm of Trojan or Greek comets ejected from their orbit in 2004 by Jupiter, and that it made its first and only loop around the sun. The swarm probably resulted from the disintegration of a larger comet.

Martinez-Oliveros’ attention was first drawn to the comet after seeing it mentioned in a summary of March 12, 2010, observations by STEREO and by SOHO, the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory. The comet’s long, bright tail of dust and ions tagged it as a sungrazing comet seen often by solar astronomers and observatories such as STEREO.

Assuming it was a going to loop around the sun, the researchers decided to see whether the STEREO data were good enough to let them calculate its trajectory.

In fact, the data were good enough to chart the comet’s approach for two days before impact.

With an estimate of the impact zone within a circle about 1,000 kilometers in diameter, they searched online data from the Mauna Loa Solar Observatory to determine if they could see the comet next to the sun’s edge in the ultraviolet region of the spectrum.

They found a short track, lasting about six minutes, just a few thousand kilometers above the sun’s surface in the million-degree corona and 100,000-degree chromosphere.

Predicted path of comet

The predicted path of the comet after it was expelled from a belt between the orbits of Jupiter (outer circle) and Mars, and before it crashed into the sun. (Claire Raftery, Juan Carlos Martinez-Oliveros, Samuel Krucker/UC Berkeley )

Based on the comet’s relatively short tail, about 3 million kilometers in length, the researchers believe that the comet contained heavier elements that do not evaporate readily. This would also explain how it penetrated so deeply into the chromosphere, surviving the strong solar wind as well as the extreme temperatures, before evaporating.

For their study, the team used the two coronagraphs on STEREO A and B and multiple instruments on SOHO, “demonstrat(ing) the importance of multi-view observations of non solar phenomena,” they wrote in their poster.

All members of the team study explosive events on the sun, such as coronal mass ejections, and the hot ionized plasmas that they throw into space. The researchers’ detour into cometary physics was purely accidental, they said.

“It was supposed to be an exercise, but it took over our lives,” Raftery said.