Mind & body, Research

When targeting cancer genes, zero in on the 1 percent

Discovery of secret door in protein may lead to more targeted cancer drugs

Most cancer drugs are designed to halt cell growth, the hallmark of cancer, and one popular target is the pathway that controls the production of a cell’s thousands of proteins.

UC Berkeley researchers have now found a promising new drug target within that pathway that is appealing, in part, because it appears to control production of only a few percent of the body’s many proteins, those critical to regulating the growth and proliferation of cells.

how eIF3d works

The protein eIF3d (left) – part of a larger mRNA binding protein – has a secret compartment that is normally blocked from access by the red string of amino acids: a sort of secret door. The right series of images shows how, when eIF3d binds to a small subset of mRNAs, the protein rearranges and the door (jagged line) opens. The secret compartment is now able to bind to the chemical handle on the end of the mRNA to initiate translation of the mRNA. (Amy Lee graphic)

The target is a protein that binds to messenger RNA, or mRNA – the cell’s blueprint for making protein – and helps get it started along the production line that ends in a fully assembled protein. A drug blocking this binding protein could shut off translation of only the growth-promoting proteins and not other life-critical proteins inside the cell.

“If cancer cells are making too much mRNA, you could shut them down by preventing them from using that mRNA to make protein,“ said Jamie Cate, a UC Berkeley professor of molecular and cell biology and of chemistry and leader of the study. “Because this binding protein is not used for general protein production – not every mRNA uses this – you may be able to get a more specific anti-cancer effect by targeting that alone.“

The finding was a surprise because the protein is part of a larger assembly of proteins called eIF3 — eukaryotic initiation factor 3 — that has been known and studied for nearly 50 years.

”No one suspected its undercover role in the cell,” said first author Amy Lee, a former UC Berkeley American Cancer Society postdoctoral fellow who is now an assistant professor at Brandeis University. “This may be because eIF3’s ability to selectively control mRNA translation is turned on only when it binds to the set of specialized mRNAs.”

Binding between eIF3 and these mRNAs opens up a pocket in eIF3 that then latches onto the end-cap of mRNA to trigger the protein production, or “translation,” process.

the secret door in the protein eIF3d

The eIF3d protein has a secret door (red) that opens when the protein binds to certain types of mRNA that are involved in cell growth and proliferation. Once the secret door is open, a new binding site becomes available for the chemical handle at the end of the mRNA to bind and initiate translation of the mRNA. (Amy Lee graphic)

“To me, it’s like finding a secret lever that opens a hidden drawer in an old-time desk,” Cate said. “The desk has been around over one and half billion years and many have studied it for decades, but we figured out how to trigger the opening.”

Lee and Cate’s research hints that this secret lever, which triggers translation of only a special subset of mRNAs — perhaps only 500 out of some 10,000 mRNAs produced by a cell — will be found to play a critical role in other diseases besides cancer, as well as in plants and animals.

“It will be exciting to look in other organisms, such as crop plants and pathogenic fungi, to find out what mRNAs this protein regulates,“ Cate said.“Down the road, one could imagine finding ways of manipulating how mRNAs bind to eIF3 in all of these different systems.“

The new findings by Cate, Lee and their UC Berkeley colleagues will be published online July 27, and in the Aug. 4 print issue of the British journal Nature.

Hiding in plain sight

Cancer is characterized by uncontrolled cell growth, which means the protein production machinery goes into overdrive to provide the building materials and control systems for new cells. Hence, biologists for decades have studied the proteins that control how genes are transcribed into mRNA and how the mRNA is read and translated into a functioning protein.

One key insight more than 40 years ago was that a so-called initiation protein must bind to a chemical handle on the end of each mRNA to start it through the protein manufacturing plant, the ribosome. Until now, this initiation protein was thought to be eIF4E (eukaryotic initiation factor 4E) for all mRNAs.

“When cells don’t control how the handle is used, cells can get out of control and cause cancer,” Cate said. “Up until now, this has been thought to be due to eIF4E that binds to the handle.”

Earlier this year, Cate and Lee discovered that for a certain specialized subset of mRNAs — most of which have been linked somehow to cancer — initiation is triggered by a different protein in eIF3. Before, that protein was thought to be just one of a dozen or so general initiation factors required for mRNA translation.

Instead, they discovered that eIF3, an assembly of 13 separate proteins, binds to unique three-dimensional structures found only in this special subset of mRNAs.

“What we found is that another protein, hiding in plain sight for over four decades, can also bind the chemical handle on the end of mRNAs to promote translation,” he said. “It’s a component of eIF3 – a protein called eIF3d – which has never before been connected to binding the handle.”

Subsequent X-ray crystallography of eIF3d revealed the structural rearrangements that must occur when eIF3 binds to the mRNA three-dimensional structures and which open up the secret compartment. The researchers plan further studies using cryoelectron microscopy to locate the actual trigger that opens the compartment.

“Basically, we found the button that opens the secret door, but we don’t really know what the button looks like yet,“ Cate said.

In addition to Cate and Lee, the coauthors of the paper are Jennifer Doudna, a UC Berkeley professor of molecular and cell biology and of chemistry, and Doudna’s former postdoc Philip Kranzusch, now a member of the faculty at Harvard Medical School and the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute. The work was funded by the National Institute of General Medical Sciences through UC Berkeley’s Center for RNA Systems Biology. Cate and Doudna are faculty scientists at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.